Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | giardini's commentslogin


You might suggest they try taking the second (or 3rd, etc.) lowest bid instead of the lowest.

Dear Mezzie,

(from your profile): "Live fast. Die young. Don't give HN an email."

I like the "Live fast", not so much the "Die young", but why not "give HN an email"?


Without an email, the account can't be retrieved if I forget the login information.

It's a reminder not to grow too attached to the account and that all things are ephemeral.


Our dormitory had two roommates, science majors, who always listened to rock music while studying. If their door was closed and you could hear music, they were lost in thought.

I never could study to music and much preferred studying in a quiet carrel in the university library.


Well, back to Britanica!

Or didn't - skip to the end!

No problem: they're always at most just one theft away from you!8-)

lava_pidgeon says >"Though I can't say about American but health care and guns are still a problem. Compare to Europe which hadn't a start up 20 years ago and "Europe" tries to fix t."<

What? health care is great in Europe and, if you want a gun, just register as a "hunter" in whatever country and take to Joe Biden's advice:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F-mztxHgYQo

Non-music(but less fun) version:

https://www.bing.com/videos/riverview/relatedvideo?q=joe+bid...

Stay on for timely warnings how "Americans could be killed by a drone."


Many of us love you behind the facade though because you are paying is so well for our services!8-))

Silly.

Everyone will press the red button and everyone will survive.


Yes, that's (overly reductively stated) the point of TFA. Except for the part where it was highlighting a survey result to the contrary, and explaining why this is irrational and doesn't likely reflect what people would actually do.

The idea behind claiming you'd choose the blue button is to appear noble and altruistic, I suppose; but I struggle to even understand that instinct. Risking one's own life to possibly save the lives of others who are demonstrably completely capable of saving themselves doesn't strike me as particularly noble.


> this is irrational and doesn’t likely reflect what people would actually do

People are irrational. I guarantee it’s likely that a lot of people would actually do it.

> The idea behind claiming you’d choose the blue button is to appear noble and altruistic.

Not at all. If the majority of people can’t be bothered to press the button that says “nobody dies as long as half of the other people say nobody dies” rather than “you don’t die,” I’m happier not being around. It’s purely selfish and blue is a win-win.


> If the majority of people can’t be bothered to press the button

It is not a matter of "can't be bothered". This is blatantly dishonest framing.

> It’s purely selfish

It costs nobody else anything. Literally all they have to do is also push red.

I said the idea is to appear noble and altruistic. Writing off alternative options as "selfish" is, inherently, doing exactly that.


You didn’t even bother reading what I wrote.

For me, blue is the purely selfish choice. Because I have no interest in living in a world where red wins a majority on this one. It’s not even a tough call.


You aren't interested in living in a world where people are generally unwilling to risk their lives for no benefit beyond the possibility of contributing to saving the lives of people who don't need saving (as they can trivially save themselves)?

Of course not.

What would you do if you found out that this world were such a world?

Because I sincerely think it is such a world, no matter what a Twitter poll says.


The only way to find out would be for this thought experiment to actually occur, in which case I would do nothing, because I would be dead.

Either I live with a restored faith in humanity, or I die and it's none of my concern.

>Everyone will not just. If your solution to some problem relies on "If everyone would just..." then you do not have a solution. Everyone is not going to just. At not time in the history of the universe has everyone just, and they're not going to start now.

Good luck getting your 5 month old daughter to pick red when her favorite color is blue.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: